In a recent case called DWP V Kiani, Ms Kiani, a DWP Work Coach, accessed her adult son’s Universal Credit account five times without a business reason or authorisation. She had significant mitigation. The DWP’s policy called this gross misconduct and listed dismissal or a final written warning as options. She was dismissed without notice. The Employment Tribunal found unfair and wrongful dismissal.

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) allowed the DWP’s appeal.

On unfair dismissal, a Tribunal must ask whether dismissal was a reasonable option for the employer. It must not ask what it would have done itself. The Tribunal had strayed into substitution. It accepted her managers reasonably believed she was guilty but then formed its own view of her mitigation. It read the policy as requiring a final written warning, which was incorrect.

On wrongful dismissal, the Tribunal must decide for itself whether what the employee did was a fundamental breach of contract. The fundamental breach relied upon here was the accessing of information in breach of policy. However, the Tribunal wrongly considered whether it amounted to a breach of the implied term of mutual trust and confidence. More significantly, when analysing whether the actual conduct complained of amounted to gross misconduct, the Tribunal included reference to mitigating factors. Those factors did not alter the facts of the conduct, and the tribunal should only have been making an objective assessment of the facts.